Bit of a different team, bad or good option?

[Meister21]

Backs: Scotland, Goddard, Suckling, Conca, Suban, Clarke, Mohr (Smedts,Wilkes)
Mids: Swan, Murphy, Thompson, Dal Santo, Wingard, Hampton (Clifton,Miles)
Rucks: McIntosh, Giles (Stephensen, Rowe)
Fwds: Johnson, Beams, Goodes, Fyfe, Lewis, Winderlich, Saad (Kerridge,Sexton)
$68,900 left

[Windigo]

I'd like to think of Beams as a upgrade target after Collingwood's bye.

Plenty of cash. So why not oust beams and get in the Buddster?

Rucks on paper look wear IMO. You'd be hoping Macca is scoring at a fair clip to off set the the unproven Giles at AFL level.

[Meister21]

Just with a couple of changes.....

Backs: Scotland, Goddard, Duffield, Conca, Buntine, Clarke, Mohr (Smedts,Wilkes)
Mids: Swan, Murphy, Thompson, Dal Santo, Barlow, Hampton (Pfieffer,Miles)
Rucks: McIntosh, Giles (Stephensen, Rowe)
Fwds: Johnson, Beams, Goodes, Fyfe, Lewis, Winderlich, Saad (Kerridge,Sexton)
$17,400 left

Just hoping Beams will be more consistent early and has DPP

Rucks are ordinary but hopefully score Well for price from TOG?