Rate my supercoach.

[gossiboy]

Hey guys, I've been playing supercoach for a couple of years so I have an idea of what I'm doing, just thought I'd get a few more opinions on my first attempt at a 2012 team.

Remaining salary cap: $150,800 (I want to use it but not sure where.)

Defenders:
Goddard (StK), Deledio (Rich), Broughton (Frem), Grimes (Melb), Lake (WB), Tomlinson (GWS), Ellis (Rich) Subs: L. Brown (Adel), Buntine (GWS)

Midfielders:
Ablett (C) (GC), Watson (Ess), Swan (VC) (Coll), Bartel (Geel), Coniglio (GWS), Mitchell (Syd) Subs: McDonald (GWS), Shiel (GWS)

Rucks:
Jamar (Melb), Maric (Rich) Subs: Stephenson (Geel), Giles (GWS)

Forwards:
Johnson (Geel), Martin (Rich), Cloke (Coll), Brown (Bris), Gunston (Haw), Porplyzia (Adel), Zorko (Bris) Subs: Saad (StK), Hampton (GWS)

[Sparxx]

Use your cash to Upgrade your rucks. Maric is a nice option, he'll get games for Richmond now that Vickery is their new CHF. Upgrade Jamar to a premium. I had Jamar last year and he hurt me.

Brilliant midfield, no faults there at all. I'd be careful with those forwards though. Having Brown and Porplyzia in the same team is something I wouldn't do - good to see you have the balls for it though. Gunston will turn out to be a frickin gem if he comes good, but obviously not much has been said about him at this time of year regarding SC.

[lucky]

i dont like 3 people from the same team even if they are just rookies cos it becomes hard to cover them in the byes but thats just being picky
use the money to upgrade one of our rucks
the rest looks pretty solid

[PICCOLLO]

Upgrade bartel and jamar.
Selwood and sandi my suggestions.

[gossiboy]

Upgrade bartel and jamar.
Selwood and sandi my suggestions.

I know i have a lot of GWS players but the fact of the matter is that they have the best rookie in the league and most of them (if not all) will be traded for the purpose of upgrading by halfway through the year.

[gossiboy]

Upgraded Jamar to Mumford. What do you guys think of downgrading Swan to Barlow and upgrading Porplyzia to J. Riewoldt?

[PICCOLLO]

Upgrade bartel and jamar.
Selwood and sandi my suggestions.

I know i have a lot of GWS players but the fact of the matter is that they have the best rookie in the league and most of them (if not all) will be traded for the purpose of upgrading by halfway through the year.

Didnt mention that?  The reason to upgrade to selwood is to save trades getting the best premiums in.  Jamar and bartel arent in the upper premium range and arent likely to get there so why start with them? Lots of gws rookies is fine

[gossiboy]

Upgrade bartel and jamar.
Selwood and sandi my suggestions.

I know i have a lot of GWS players but the fact of the matter is that they have the best rookie in the league and most of them (if not all) will be traded for the purpose of upgrading by halfway through the year.

Didnt mention that?  The reason to upgrade to selwood is to save trades getting the best premiums in.  Jamar and bartel arent in the upper premium range and arent likely to get there so why start with them? Lots of gws rookies is fine

Quoted the wrong person, my bad. I like selwood but Jimmy B still consistently knocks out 100+ and Selwood is just out of my current price range.

[gossiboy]

i dont like 3 people from the same team even if they are just rookies cos it becomes hard to cover them in the byes but thats just being picky
use the money to upgrade one of our rucks
the rest looks pretty solid

I know i have a lot of GWS players but the fact of the matter is that they have the best rookie in the league and most of them (if not all) will be traded for the purpose of upgrading by halfway through the year.

[PICCOLLO]

Jamar to jacobs and bartel to selwood?  Selly is now capt and got concussed which brought his avg down.  Bartel a gun but he isnt a top 10 midfielder.  You need to have top 10 mids to maximise your team potential.

[gossiboy]

Alright so I upgraded Jamar to Luenberger/McEvoy (undecided at the moment) Upgraded Bartel to Selwood, downgraded Swann to Bernie Vince and upgraded Porplyzia to Jarrad Waite. Thoughts?

Remaining salary cap: $100

[PICCOLLO]

Better but porps isnt a bad guy to keep.  Will hold his place and make you money.  Waite is a risk bcos of injury and suspension.  Dont mind vince.  Mcevoy my pick but adel play gcs,pa and gws twice (only 2 teams do his) so jacobs could go massive.