Dids, Porps or Winder

[Matticus]

Trying to decide on a seasoned forward who, in the past, has posted some sweet scores either Didak, Winderlich or Porplyzia anyone in DT world have an opinion, it would help with my decisions. ;D

[picker_man]

who knows what didak we will c this yr but is prolly the most proven out of these hence the highest price tag by a fair bit so its a bigger risk, winderlich mite not b able to keep up with game being out 4 so long and could find it hard to get into the bombers midfield i would steer clear of him, porpz is the cheapest nd has more upside to him with a easy draw and improving midfield should c alot of ball down his end out of these 3 i would take him

but if u can afford didak i would look at christensen, brown and dangerfield who should all preform better then these 3

[Colliwobblers]

+1 exactly what pickers said go one of the three he suggested or a rook, there are going to be some GUN rooks this year, and i just uncovered another i think will tear it up if he gets a good run of early games in Taylor Adams, then there is treloar smedts zorko hampton just to name a handful, guns and rook for me axcept one of the 3 pickers mentioned i can fit in.

[Football Factory]

Hard question they all have their upsides... Didak underpriced if he can regain his form with a higher ceiling than the other two .... Porps underpriced and alot cheaper if his shoulders stay together could be a good pick... Window licker again cheap and with a bit of luck could rise in value but not by much in my opinion. I would rate them Didak then Porps, window licker

[Matticus]

Thanks boys

[elephants]

Nah, Nah and Nah but if I was going to choose I'd go the Porpoise. Didak seems to have lost his place in the mids to younger players (wellingham, thomas, sidebottom and blair) while Winders has lost his greatest weapon following his injury... speed.

Porps if any.

[Windigo]

None of them. But the cheapest option would be the best.

[DT Gun]

not sure why everyone isnt taking a closer look at the porpus for 200k. Coniglio is 170 and the porpus will average the same if not more as a forward.

[The F.A.R.K.]

DT gun now i realise why your boo ratio is so high...hahaha

Porps is coming off shoulder surgery and has had that problem his whole career. At the best porps will average mid 70s and then you have the injuries to worry about.

Coniglio has had no real injury concerns, plays midfield and as a top draft pick is expected to average at least 80. David Swallow averaged 80+ and Coniglio should be the same

[Ziplock]

Swallow averaged 71 from memory :P

I actually agree with DT  Guns call- but to be fair, not very many people are keen on coniglio anyway due to his price tag.

I really doubt Coniglio will average 80+... 70+ is far more likely.

[owenbond007]

Im with DT Gun too. Porps is up and about from previous articles ive read and i think i recall cogs had a minor injury, but dont quote me on the latter.

I wouldnt write off winders yet and would keep a close eye on these 2 over cup. Brown for me all the way. Didak would have to juice up and play out of his skin to even get any consideration.

[elephants]

DT gun now i realise why your boo ratio is so high...hahaha

Porps is coming off shoulder surgery and has had that problem his whole career. At the best porps will average mid 70s and then you have the injuries to worry about.

Coniglio has had no real injury concerns, plays midfield and as a top draft pick is expected to average at least 80. David Swallow averaged 80+ and Coniglio should be the same

Coniglio has had a bit of knee problems that hampered him during the under 18's state comp...

[DT Gun]

DT gun now i realise why your boo ratio is so high...hahaha

Porps is coming off shoulder surgery and has had that problem his whole career. At the best porps will average mid 70s and then you have the injuries to worry about.

Coniglio has had no real injury concerns, plays midfield and as a top draft pick is expected to average at least 80. David Swallow averaged 80+ and Coniglio should be the same

Porps had the entire season off last year has had a massive pre season and sanderson absolutely loves him. He has averaged high 70's before and if you expect coniglio to average 80+ you have too high of an expectation for rookies, you forget he will be a boy against men.

Crows also have a lot easier run this year than in any previous years! Last time porps played there was no GWS or GC and they play them twice each this year..

[Swallow12]

Porps, easy draw and super cheap

[Matticus]

After a bit more research I think porps. I try to save some cash by picking a seasoned player, who has know to score in the past, who for one reason or another is cheap at the beginning of the new season hence i have lake in my backline and j. brown in my forward.