Zaharakis or Cloke

[Tom_16]

No doubt both of these guys will be good picks this year but who will be better? Did some research on Cloke and when dawes was out of the side he averaged 102 over 7 games and only averaged 92.8 when he was in the side. If Dawes plays 22 games this year will this trend continue? Zaharakis on the other hand aparently has some 'dodgy' knees but people are saying he will play more in the midfield where he averaged 100 odd in the back half of last season. Please vote, thanks.

[Football Factory]

No doubt both of these guys will be good picks this year but who will be better? Did some research on Cloke and when dawes was out of the side he averaged 102 over 7 games and only averaged 92.8 when he was in the side. If Dawes plays 22 games this year will this trend continue? Zaharakis on the other hand aparently has some 'dodgy' knees but people are saying he will play more in the midfield where he averaged 100 odd in the back half of last season. Please vote, thanks.

Im on the Zaharakis train for the reasons you stated

[Tom_16]

No doubt both of these guys will be good picks this year but who will be better? Did some research on Cloke and when dawes was out of the side he averaged 102 over 7 games and only averaged 92.8 when he was in the side. If Dawes plays 22 games this year will this trend continue? Zaharakis on the other hand aparently has some 'dodgy' knees but people are saying he will play more in the midfield where he averaged 100 odd in the back half of last season. Please vote, thanks.

Im on the Zaharakis train for the reasons you stated

Yeah i'm very tempted to jump on but i'll be kicking myself if i get zaka and he gets injured and cloke stays injury free. How seriously do people rate his knee issue?

[nichsa673]

Zaharakis comfortably, until i heard of his knee tendonitis problems. will have to see NAB cup form.

[footy4life]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/essendons-david-zaharakis-a-rising-don-but-dont-mention-that-anzac-day-goal/story-e6frf9jf-1226213548242

"Zaharakis has now joined his teammates for full pre-season training having shrugged off the knee tendinitis that bothered him throughout the 2011 season".

looks good to go :)

[Colliwobblers]

tough choice and i will have both (probably) by the end of the season, BUT i'd start with Zaka. I am. :)

[elephants]

Zaharakis. Lock and Load.
Wanna see how the return of Dawes effects Cloke's scores before jumping on him :P

[Windigo]

I'd still take Cloke. Dawes is second fiddle.  :)

[elephants]

I'd still take Cloke. Dawes is second fiddle.  :)

At the start of last season when Dawes was a target Cloke's scoring was decreased...

[Tom_16]

I'd still take Cloke. Dawes is second fiddle.  :)

Dawes may be second fiddle but he does take away from cloke's scoring.