Forced Trade/s ? How would you handle this?

Started by Colliwobblers, April 02, 2012, 03:50:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

How Would you Do it?

YES - out the injured howard and upgrade / downgrade = 2 trades.
12 (31.6%)
NO - just straight swap Howard to Dempsey/Golby = 1 trade
9 (23.7%)
NO - KEEP Howard for 4 weeks injured
1 (2.6%)
NO - just downgrade Howard to a rook = 1 trade
13 (34.2%)
NO - something different - please post
3 (7.9%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Justin Bieber

Quote from: tabs on April 02, 2012, 05:21:59 PM
Quote from: whatlez on April 02, 2012, 05:13:50 PM
Howard to Hargrave? Or do you have him?

did you not read what colli wrote??

Quote from: Colliwobblers on April 02, 2012, 03:50:17 PM

DEF: GODDARD / DELIDIO / SHAW / BROUGHTON / HARGRAVE / HOWARD / CLARKE (BUGG - ELLIS)

lol, I don't pay attention half the time....

Don't get Birchall he's a dud ;)

owenbond007

I wouldnt make any trades this week. Id hang onto him for a week, if someone else goes down you can then do your double trade to get birchall. If nobody goes down id think about trading him down to the best possible cash cow.

Colliwobblers

Quote from: owenbond007 on April 02, 2012, 05:33:21 PM
I wouldnt make any trades this week. Id hang onto him for a week, if someone else goes down you can then do your double trade to get birchall. If nobody goes down id think about trading him down to the best possible cash cow.

makes sense just tempting to go the trade this week and be guaranteed more points especially in teh double trade option, but waiting makes sense, I have nailed every rook except ledger and (dickson,hall) those two are pretty average but if they play they stay.

T Dog

i reckon Geelong defenders will get some work this week CW. Scarllett out..Guthrie may stay..Smedts may fire..tho they wont get a a gun forward yet

Colliwobblers

what do you mean by they wont get a gun fwd yet- i had guthrie most pre season (NAB) then went scared of his JS and put clarke back in. Of all the rookie DT defenders you have named the two i think are worthwhile - maybe morris or tomlinson or townsend but not really convinced on those.

big wraps on both guthrie and smedts, think if i go down to a rook or sideways option i will do it after round 2.

the only thing that would be better done this week would be the upgrade/downgrade option to get the extra points from the trades sooner rather than later.

T Dog

CAnt see them getting Buddy or Rioli this week CW. Of course it is all about points not the trades asou say CW

Zombie2.5

i voted for howard>golby BUT i changed my mind, i reckon you should just stay put and leave howard on the bench for a game. See how the other guys you thinking of go, and if oppurtunity to downgrade someone else, i reckon lynch will stop being sub, wont be a gaff, still worried though. Howard>Birch would be ideal but i reckon keep the lynch.
Wait a week birch, adcock and co. might score bad and change your mind?
dont think it can hurt to wait a round unless your rooks arent named.