Rate my side

[The Freak]

DEF:Goddard, Deledio, R.Murphy, Broughton, Burgoyne, M.Clarke, B.Ellis (Smedts, Bugg)

MID:Ablett, Martin, J.Lewis, Sidebottom, Morabito, Shiel (L.Brown, T.Mitchell)

RUCKS: Leunberger, Giles (Rowe, Stephenson)

FWDS: Fyfe, Roughead, Beams, Gray, D. Stanley, J. Brown, Saad (T.Walsh, Kerridge)

CASH REMAINING: $4,900

[ben_020285]

Sorry mate but this side needs so much work.

BACKS: Murphy is a unique pick and could pay off but Burgoyne? Swap him for a proven SC player.

MIDS: It's better to have your MPP mid/fwd prems in your fwd line so move one of Martin, Lewis and Sidebottom into your fwd line and get rid of the other 2. You need some guns in your mids! You only have Ablett, you need at least 3 guns in your mids. Morabito is a waste of time for his price. Downgrade him to a rookie.

RUCKS: I don't agree with only having one prem in the ruck, you will lose so many points by using Giles as your number 2 ruckman. Get rid of Rowe and bring in a prem ruckman.

FWDS: This is your worst line of all. Roughead won't be playing round 1 so swap him. Gray is a muppet and plays for Port and is not a wise pick IMO. Stanley is not a mid pricer that should be chosen this year so scrap him.

Overall you really need to get rid of a lot of your mid pricers and have more guns and rookies. Your current team would get destroyed by any decent SC team.

4/10

[The Freak]

Thanks for the input back to the drawing board.

[The Freak]

Take 2:

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, R.Shaw, S.Morris, M.Clarke, Broughton, R.Murphy  (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Ablett, Sewell, Carazzo, Stanton, Shiel, L.Brown (T.Mitchell, Crozier)

RUCKS: M.Bailey, Leunberger (Stephensen, Giles)

FWDS: J. Brown, Fyfe, Beams, D.Martin, Rioli, T.Walsh, Saad (Kerridge, L.Moss)

Cash remaining :$4,300

[Ringo]

Sorry but this team needs a lot of work to,

You will be giving away points every week without 3 prems in the midfield as this where the majority of points are made.

As you may be new to SC can I suggest the following strategy for you.
List out what you consider your final SC team will look like reagardless of cap. Look at which prems you can afford in each line try for 4 def; 3 mid; 4 fwd, and rucks 1 or 2 depending on Ruck Strategy,  This will give you your 12/13 keepers.  Fill the team then with rookies or other mid price players who are really under priced prems. Have an upgrade plan in place to achieve your final team.  Hope this helps.

[The Freak]

3rd time lucky:

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Tuohy, S.Morris, M.Clarke, Broughton, R.Murphy  (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Ablett, Hodge, Carazzo, Stanton, Shiel, L.Brown (T.Mitchell, Crozier)

RUCKS: Hale, Leunberger (Stephensen, Giles)

FWDS: J. Brown, Fyfe, Beams, D.Martin, Franklin, T.Walsh, Saad (Kerridge, L.Moss)

Cash remaining :$26,500

[Griffo1982]

I'd say scrap:
Tuohy, Murphy, Carazzo, Stanton & Hale for a start.

[The Freak]

Next attempt :

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Harbrow, S.Morris, Lake, M.Clarke, Broughton (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Hodge, Ablett, Stanton, Gibbs, Shiel, T.Mitchell (L.Brown, Crozier)

RUCKS: Kreuzer, Leunberger (Stephenson, Giles)

FWD: J.Brown, Franklin, Fyfe, Beams, D.Martin, T.Walsh, Saad (Moss, Kerridge)

CASH REMAINING: $5,900

[The Freak]

Next attempt :

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Harbrow, S.Morris, Lake, M.Clarke, Broughton (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Hodge, Ablett, Moloney, Gibbs, Shiel, T.Mitchell (L.Brown, Crozier)

RUCKS: Kreuzer, Leunberger (Stephenson, Giles)

FWD: J.Brown, Franklin, Fyfe, Beams, D.Martin, T.Walsh, Saad (Moss, Kerridge)

CASH REMAINING: $6,500

[Griffo1982]

No to Harbrow & still a big no to Stanton i reckon.

[The Freak]

No Stanton there now. :)

[The Freak]

Replaced Harbrow with Laidler.

[Griffo1982]

Could you go Moloney to Barlow & upgrade Hodge or Gibbs to Swan or Pendles.
I think your barking up the wrong tree with the mid pricer in the backs ie Harbrow & Laider i'd be trying to do a shuffle & get a premium there.

[The Freak]

Lets look at this :


DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Suckling, S.Morris, M.Clarke, Broughton, Lake (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Swan, Ablett, Dal Santo, McCarthy, Shiel, Mitchell (L.Brown, Crozier)

RUCKS: Kreuzer,Leunberger (Giles, Stephensphon)

FWDS: Brown, Fyfe, Beams, Matin, Franklin, Saad, Walsh (Kerridge, Sexton)

CASH LEFT: $20,900