Drummond or Broughton?

Started by roo boys!, July 13, 2009, 09:37:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

roo boys!

I'm trading geary and I can't decide between gregbroughton or josh drummond who do u think they r bout same price so I dunno

Alex7089

You missed out on Broughton should of gotten him when he was 83,000 and if you couldn't then get him the next week but now he has come up almost 400k so he won't be n option this year get drummond he is probably better anyway

roo boys!

nah i already got broughton cos apparently drummond is prone to injurys but i got him cos his b/e is 4 so i wanna get him b4 he goes up more

hibbo

Wait you traded on a monday?

chris

Yep firstly hope Broughton doesn't get injured at training or dropped(stranger things have happened).

Secondly would have went Drummond(experience) of Broughton(first yearer in good form but can easily have a few off games as is expected from first yearers)

toodledock

had broughton from the start was actually thinking grimes for drummond?

heard

i wouldnt recommend getting broughton this far into the season, it's his first year in AFL, surely hes on fire at the moment, but i wouldnt expect it to last much longer, better off getting a more experienced player.. or better yet, shudv picked up broughton 10 games back :-X

Alex7089

Quote from: roo boys! on July 14, 2009, 01:37:49 AM
nah i already got broughton cos apparently drummond is prone to injurys but i got him cos his b/e is 4 so i wanna get him b4 he goes up more
Mate, he has already come up so much he is almost not worth gettting soon he will come back down to earth I mean lets face it yes he is on a hot streak and yes he has a low BE but he is playing in a terrible team that is tanking and he is a firs year player it pains me to say this but he is not going to keep on scoring like this it is as simple as that.