The Cavemen Supercoach First Draft. Just Do It!

Started by Cookie Monster, February 01, 2012, 06:26:07 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cookie Monster

Backs: Goddard, Murphy, Yarran, Hurn, Gilbert, Buntine, Docherty
                      Ellis, Smedts.

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Judd, Kavanagh, M.Grigg, Wingard.
                  Zorko, Shiel

Rucks: Kruezer, Jolly
Downie, Michael

Fowards: Franklin, Johnson, Martin, Zaharakis, Brown, Garlett, T.Adams
                          Kerridge, Croizer


I have 5k in the bank

I think i have spread the teams out well especially with the GWS teams.

please give me some feedback and a rate.

Cookie Monster


Luigi197

Backline is quite risky. I would say Goddard over Gilbert, not both. Hurn/Yarran/Murphy; not all super premiums, not all consistent, and all don't have the greatest of possibility to get over 90 every match. They are in the mid-price range, and i would not pick them, as the season will start, we will not see big enough SC scores, and we will watch their Breakeven rise. The would come the dreaded de-preciation. Uniqueness and riskiness is fine on some levels, but sometimes a bit more average fluency is the way to go. I would say upgrade one to Deledio or Broughton, and downgrade the other to Lake or M Clarke.
The midfield is fine, but come the time when the teams are released for round 1, make sure those rookies are not only playing, but have a good role to play.
No Giles/Stephenson bench combo? I'm no expert at ruck choosing, but they seem kinda popular, and youd hate to miss the boat wouldn't you?
The rest is fine by me :)

Rate your team: 8/10
Watch NAB Cup and don't be afraid to just go with the flow 8) Good Job!