Winderlich or Lake

[underdog11]

I know they play diffrent positions but i could get a forward rookie and lake or a back rookie and winderlich, so winderlich or lake?

[Windigo]

I wouldn't touch Lake. You'd be very brave IMO to have him in your starting squad.

Winderlich is the safer option.

And when I get around to planning a team I'll definitely consider him.

[CuStArDaRm]

Ummmmmm......Lake by the length of Flemington straight!

Their both risks but you know Lake has premium potential,
Winderlich is 'NOT' a premium nor has he ever been in either comp.

Preseason and nab depending of course. Lake by far imo.

[elephants]

Winderlich had averaged 90+ in the past. That's premium status for your 5th/6th/7th forward position.

[Phasir]

There's valid reasons to pick both of them.. They could both end up averaging over 90 this season(2012) but I personally won't have either in my team, it could hurt me in the long run, but its just my personal choice with Browny & either Grimes/Waters in my team I'd prefer not to have too many injury-returns in the team

[Windigo]

Lake has had only one 'good' dt season.

Winderlich is still the safer pick from where I sit anyhow.