Selwood vs Murphy vs Thompson

[Tom_16]

After my recent decision to start without swan i'm not sure who to pick. My other mids are Ablett, Rockliff and barlow but i'm not sure who else to get. Selwood, Murphy, Thompson are all guns but i'm not sure who to get. Thompson as wel all know has a dream draw, Murphy will avoid the No.1 tag because of Judd and Selwood has the captaincy and an injury affected 27 which brought down his avg so he is underpriced. Who should i get any why? thanks

[YOUNG24]

Got Jelwood and Scotty T both in ATM - reckon Jelwood will go up a notch with the captaincy and Scotty has a killer draw and should rack them up.

[Bazinga]

Jelwood easily. Underpriced and will dominate the Cats midfield this year.

Lets just hope he doesn't get knocked out after ten minutes again this season   :P

[thatguy]

im going with the ASS starting mids and barlow as my 4th. reckon joel will relish the captaincy and want to really lead from the front

[Doyle]

Selwood if you want an outright gun, but Thompson has a really good draw, I'm personally considering them both in the same team

[Windigo]

Seeing a few going off Swan. Is it wise?

[picker_man]

will have all 3 by the end of the yr but taking selwood cause of his value and thomo cause his draw to start with
yeh windigo im not startn with him but he's my 1st upgrade target guess we'll soon c if it pays of or not

[Doyle]

Seeing a few going off Swan. Is it wise?

I was planning to do it, but the more I think about it, the dumber the idea is  ;)

[Windigo]

will have all 3 by the end of the yr but taking selwood cause of his value and thomo cause his draw to start with
yeh windigo im not startn with him but he's my 1st upgrade target guess we'll soon c if it pays of or not

Fair enough. I've gone with Swan every year and this year will be no exception.  ;)

[Tom_16]

Seeing a few going off Swan. Is it wise?

It was a tough decision but i just don't believe he will average as high as last year whilst selwood is underpriced and i believe his average is on the way up. If i didn't have ablett i wouldn't do it but i do and i see swan as an upgrade target.