scotland + 1 or 2 x forward upgrades?

[bundyboy]

ok - now pay attention for just a moment please... :)

only back upgrade I'm considering is Puopolo or Petrenko > Scotland  probably gives me maybe 20 points...

plus then probably Fyfe/Buddy > didak  putting didak on the field, and Petrie or Yarran on bench.  probably + 20 points again..

or

leave backline and 2 forward trades instead - I think my fwds are a bit weaker than my defence at the moment, but so is everyone else with outs this week....

current fwds are: 
chappy, N Roo, Petrie, Goodes, I Smith, Mzungu, Yarran ....  Buddy, Fyfe on the pine.

my thinking - Buddy > Didak and   
Fyfe > Cloke/Higgins  .......  puts Yarran and Petrie on the bench in their place. 

so didak & cloke v's Yarran & Petrie - will it give me more points than the scotland trade ??

so if you follow all that - you must be a genius - so your opinion much appreciated  ;D ;D

[langej]

I have a similar Problem - ConsideringHiggins/ROK (are you?) AND either:

A. H Scotland for Adcock or Stanley Back Option
B. Stevie J/Cloak in for Prestia

[Possumo]

Hmm I think the Poo will go pretty well this weekend... so I'd go the double forward upgrade.

[bundyboy]

thinking double forward option myself....

cloke / dids / ROK ...I think....I keep looking at higgins, but not sure if I can bring myself to trade him back in after giving him the flick earlier in the year !

[PowerBug]

So in short it's Scotland vs Cloke/Higgins. I'd go Scotland.