Polkinghorne, Rich, Ziebell or Otten

[Nooka]

Out of these four players who do you think should start on the field? Or are there any other cheap price/rookie players who are worth considering for a mid on field spot??

[pies09]

Personally I feel prety confident about starting Ziebell, impressed in his first game and was one of Norths best in their game against Fremantle today. I think Mitch Robinson of the blues might get a few games early and if he continues to impress who knows, might play most of the season. Sidebottom has also been very impressive in collingwoods intraclub matches, and i think Mick would have to play him sometime in the preseason. Rich and Polkinghorne are also good chances to start round 1 but so far Rich hasnt looked like a great DTer.

[mcwarne]

Rich is becoming a worry as almost everyone has him as a lock starter and I was so convinced that he was going to be another Palmer. Looks like Voss is going to ease him into action as they have more depth of onballers which Freo didnt have last year when they debuted RP. But I am stuck starting him now and I have also jumped on Ziebell (if you are reading this Dean Laidley......***** off and stop sniggering how you intend to pull the rug out from under us all, yet again).