1 trade left, which line to upgrade?

[bmac25]

I have 1 trade left and have the week off as I'm in the preilim.  Unsure of who to upgrade.

B: Goddard, Deledio, Fisher, Broughton, R Murphy, Puppolo, Gilbert (Gibbs, Lower, Tuohy)

M: Pendles, Swan, Boyd, GAJ, Mitchell, Cotchin (Krakouer, I Smith, B Jacobs)

R: Sandi, Cox (Petrie, McCulloch)

F: Pav, Goodes, Fyfe, Franklin, Rioli, O'Keefe, Higgins (Mzungu, Richardson, Callinan)

With $113k in the bank

Do I trade:

a) Gilbert, Puppolo or Lower for a decent defender (if so which one)

b) Cotchin for Selwood

c) Higgins for Cloke

d) none of the above - suggestions welcome

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

[ben_020285]

Lower > Enright if you can afford it. Geelong would have has it's bye by then.

Then swap Enright on the field for either Gilbert or Puopolo.

[bmac25]

Definitely worth considering, cheers.

[FonFatty]

I have 1 trade left and have the week off as I'm in the preilim.  Unsure of who to upgrade.

B: Goddard, Deledio, Fisher, Broughton, R Murphy, Puppolo, Gilbert (Gibbs, Lower, Tuohy)

M: Pendles, Swan, Boyd, GAJ, Mitchell, Cotchin (Krakouer, I Smith, B Jacobs)

R: Sandi, Cox (Petrie, McCulloch)

F: Pav, Goodes, Fyfe, Franklin, Rioli, O'Keefe, Higgins (Mzungu, Richardson, Callinan)

With $113k in the bank

Do I trade:

a) Gilbert, Puppolo or Lower for a decent defender (if so which one)

b) Cotchin for Selwood

c) Higgins for Cloke

d) none of the above - suggestions welcome

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

I have 2 options for you
A= Swap Krak into your fwd line and bring in Cloke,
or
B= Bring in Boomer Harvey for Krak..

You cant go wrong with both these options, Boomer gives you a little bit more flexibility, can put him into fwd line for Higgins or if you follow option A you have a player that should finish the year of very strongly.. Is he chasing Buddy for the Coleman?

[bmac25]

Very helpful...so I'm upgrading:

a) Lower for Enright

b) Cotchin for Selwood, or

c) Krakouer for Cloke/Boomer.

Anyone else have an opinion on this?

[Torress]

well I wouldn't be trading til Fri next week m8- that's my opinion! pies travel to perth next week, wait and see who gets the week off? team looks solid tho, boomer would not be a bad option with the run home. but next week is another week, wait and see who  your opposition will be and then assess the trade situation. im taking overall is out of reach, have a week off sc and look at it next week, there could be a nasty injury or suspension! I don't get why u have Petrie on youre bench without the ability to use mpp!

[bmac25]

Won't be touching my team til late next week, just wanted a few suggestions.  Petrie is unfortunate, in hindsight I probably should have had J tippett in my fwd line bench.  As it happened I now have a quality backup ruck should sandi or cox get injured/suspended/rested.

[Ringo]

Question who do you think will score the most points for the final 2 rounds out of Petrie, Cloke or harvey. If you think Petrie then you still have the option of trading Richardson to Tippett/Lobbe to bring Petrie back as another alternative.