Round 23 B.Gibbs

Started by Dan1234756, August 15, 2011, 05:20:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

To Sideways trade B.Gibbs in Round 23 or not

Put Gibbs on the pine - My team is good enough to get through
19 (76%)
Sideways Trade to another Premium
6 (24%)

Total Members Voted: 3

Marstar

Quote from: CrowsFan on August 16, 2011, 01:44:13 AM
Quote from: roo boys! on August 15, 2011, 05:32:52 PM
I'm tossing up whether to trade him and keep Judd, or keep Judd and trade Gibbs :-\
You realise that in both these scenarios you are trading Gibbs and keeping Judd right? :P

+1

Dan1234756

I suppose only keep gibbs if you have sufficient cover on the bench already. I have all premium backs but little to no cover on my bench (Downgraded my bench to get the premiums). Also, to have over 500k on the bench does not sit well.

locky

I've got a similar situation:

Judd and Gibbs (and Heppel on the field)
3 trades, 100k, and a bye this week

I have Rawlings as cover, but I don't think he's good enough, I was thinking of trading him for Suckling this week when I can afford him (only just have enough). That would give me cover for Gibbs. And I was thinking of using Smith as cover for Judd, leaving me with 2 trades for the GF; or sideways trade Judd leaving me 1 trade

Dan1234756

I have the cash and the trades to upgrade one of my def bench.....Thinking either BURCHALL or SUCKLING....Havent decided

Fletch74

I'll be trading him and Yarran in Rd 23. Will move Gibbs to the midfield and trade him there if there are no decent defenders.

I will keep Judd for Rd 24.