Urgent help needed!

Started by JB0016, August 19, 2011, 07:20:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Trades?

Mzungu to Blease and Z.Smith to Goldstein
4 (33.3%)
Harris to Blease and Z.Smith to Petrie
8 (66.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

JB0016

Hey guys, need your help. Playing in 4 semi finals after having a horror start to the finals.

Looking to upgrade my ruck area.

Which one should I do?

Mzungu to Blease and Z.Smith to Goldstein

or

Harris to Blease and Z.Smith to Petrie?

ossie85


Harris has retired... so that one

JB0016

Quote from: ossie85 on August 19, 2011, 07:21:43 PM

Harris has retired... so that one
Yeah it will give me greater bench coverage in the midfield...but is Goldstein gonna score higher than Petrie?

ossie85


Probably... But I prefer the extra bench cover

bluedreamin

Seriously... a choice between a retired player or Mzungu????
The difference between Petrie and Goldstein would be negligible so Petrie and Mzungu for mine.

JB0016

Quote from: bluedreamin on August 19, 2011, 07:57:07 PM
Seriously... a choice between a retired player or Mzungu????
The difference between Petrie and Goldstein would be negligible so Petrie and Mzungu for mine.
I also have have 10 playing backmens.

So maybe sacrifice Puopolo to Jonas and get Goldstein.

Really want Goldstein into the team as SC really favours rucks with their scores.

Ringo

Get Buddy now Although playing Carlton tonight then has Doggies and GC so could go big.

dmac07

I wouldve gone goldstein assuming mzungu is not a starter and you have one other playing back up. Goldstein should score more than petrie, possibly a lot more, and at this stage of the season you've got to go for broke and not worry about the best possible back up for just a few rounds.