My Judd/Kerr Conundrum

mitchwiz · February 25, 2009, 07:54:26 AM

My team is progressing along nicely and pretty close to as finalised as i'll get (first year/bench players aside) but i've come to a fork in the road...

My third midfielder Judd or Kerr?

If i go Judd i'm left with Cox/Fraser in the ruck, but if i go Kerr i can afford Cox/Hille...

What should i do, Judd or Hille????

mEnty · February 25, 2009, 08:10:40 AM

Think Kerr will struggle a bit this year to produce the tons. I don't rate Fraser much. Have you thought about another midfielder apart from Judd/Kerr that spot...Foley around that Kerr price.

dreamteamking · February 25, 2009, 08:11:27 AM

judd

he'll have a big year

mitchwiz · February 25, 2009, 08:26:02 AM

mEnty - i have Foley in the side already, i agree that Kerr will cop a massive tag this year but the names around his price didn't strike me...

any quality suggestions around $340 000?

Truth be told i'm a massive C Judd fan, thats clouding my judgement as far as he is concerned i guess...

mEnty · February 25, 2009, 09:51:26 AM

Mitch, I am exactly the same, huge Judd fan...just don't know if hes going to improve much DT wise.

Maybe you could consider a lower valued player (say between 200-300k) who is set rise (see other mids discussions, plenty around) and use the cash to upgrade elsewhere.

vitch · February 25, 2009, 10:49:19 AM

Judd no contest, may also consider R Ladson, his DT points have increased each year for the last 5 years ave nearly 80 last year - consistent, could do worse @ $335k (although I've got in as a back)

Hawks_1976 · February 25, 2009, 10:51:49 PM

Maybe consider Brent Reilly at $284k, should average 75 - 80?
Perhaps Masten will be the beneficiary of Kerr being tagged and improve his DT numbers? ($306k).

love4thegame · February 25, 2009, 11:34:41 PM

judd hands down.

Hawks_1976 · February 26, 2009, 10:04:52 PM

We are talking DT, so I'd suggest selecting neither Judd or Kerr.

Judd: As mentioned in other threads, Judd can average around 30 possies a game yet rarely break through for a DT ton because he takes little marks. SC recognises his hard work under packs and effectiveness, meaning his SC scores are usually much higher than DT.

Kerr: Too many negatives. Will recieve the best tag each game. Has had a bad history with injuries. Has a bad history at the tribunal.

Suggestions:
Look at Gibbs instead of Judd. Only 10k more and will outscore Judd in DT comfortably.
Around Kerr's price as mentioned, Foley. Sure to receive less attention this year and works hard to get the footy.

StantonLEGEND · February 28, 2009, 03:56:09 AM

daniel jackson will have a massive year
also andrew lovertt could be a worth while risk

My Judd/Kerr Conundrum

dreamteamking