Fwd Upgrade: Trav, Pav or Fyfe

Started by jk17, July 13, 2011, 12:18:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who is the better option?

Travis Cloke
5 (31.3%)
Matthew Pavlich
6 (37.5%)
Nat Fyfe
5 (31.3%)
Other (please specify)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

jk17

I've kinda ignored my fwdline a bit, so need to upgrade.
My fwdline is: Buddy, Goodes, Sylvia, Higgins, N. Riewoldt, Mzungu, I.Smith[Krak in mids] (Howe, CRich, Jippett[Petrie in ruck])

Who should I upgrade to? Cloke, Pav or Fyfe or other? 10 trades. Cheers.

Bak2Form

i like fyfe i dont know why everyone is going Pav, his more consistant and has a higher average.

Windigo

Pav for consistency but don't expect anything over 105+ too often.

Fyfe for a bit unique but his shoulder are a worry.

Cloke will get you some massive scores but in the past can go through some lean patches.

If your betting man, I'd go Cloke in terms of scoring potential. But Fyfe or Pav for a bit more peace of mind.

Edge

all year i been hearing people say fyfe's shoulder is a worry..
and im just wondering,  has he actuallly been hurt this year? and has he missed any games?

hally25547

fyfe cos i love the bloke but really either of pav or fyfe are good option - cloke could be inconsistent although he has the gc coming up - that could be huge!

I think fyfe hurt his shoulder against richmond early in the year but correct me if i am wrong