Which path should I go down?

Started by roo boys!, July 05, 2011, 08:37:06 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which trade option?

OPTION ONE - Sandi->Lobbe & Bewick -> premium mid
6 (54.5%)
OPTION TWO - Sandi->Lobbe & Smith/Mzungu -> Ablett
5 (45.5%)
Other?
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

roo boys!

Team is as follows:
Deledio, Newman, Gibbs, Goddard, Bock, Heppell, Puopolo (Duffield, Toy, Guthrie)

Swan, A.Swallow, Judd, Hodge, Bewick, Jacobs (Moloney, Pavlich, Irons)

Petrie, Smith (Sandilands, Spencer)

Franklin, Chapman, Higgins, N.Roo, Didak (he back?), Lynch(GC), I.Smith (Mzungu, Rioli, Richardson)

9 trades, $44,700 in the bank.

Obviously it looks quite depleted for the multi-bye round, but just assuming when it is as full strength Puopolo, Bewick, Jacobs, Lynch and I.Smith would all be on the bench. With Sandilands, I have two options IMO.

OPTION ONE:
Trade Sandi to Lobbe
Trade Bewick to a premium mid (Can Afford Marc murphy down)
Then next week:
Trade one of my rookie forwards down to J.Tippet
Trade Z.Smith to Cox

OPTION TWO:
Trade Sandi to Lobbe
Swap I.Smith/Mzungu/Didak into the mids and trade them for Ablett
Then next week:
Trade one of my rookie forwards down to J.Tippet
Trade Z.Smith to Cox


Personally I like the second one, what are everyone else's opinions?

Ringo

Why not go Straight Sandilands to Cox now.
Then Smith to Lobbe - Smith seems to be struggling at the moment and price is going down.
Then next week look at your upgrades.

Tiggerfan

Both good but you'd have to go with Ablett with the big scores he's been pumping out. It'd be handy if you had another mid/fwd link in the mids. Prehaps next week go Bewick to Callinan, get the link and a bit of cash....

Ermaz

close one, MPP is crucial so id get rid of bewick

ajjewell

I'd be getting Callinan this week while he is on the bubble

scotty_222

Quote from: ajjewell on July 05, 2011, 02:37:09 PM
I'd be getting Callinan this week while he is on the bubble

didnt he do his hammy?
plus adelaide have the bye

Luigi197

Did option two cause i saw GAJ there, but could go either way.
You really should get Ablett in, but you wanna trade Bewick i'd assume...

Master Q


ajjewell

Quote from: scotty_222 on July 05, 2011, 02:42:06 PM
Quote from: ajjewell on July 05, 2011, 02:37:09 PM
I'd be getting Callinan this week while he is on the bubble
plus adelaide have the bye
Forgot about this, my bad