Rate My Supercoach + Trades help

[dons95]

Hi I am currently looking to try win my League, i will most likely finish first and win my first final, if i am correct this means i have a bye when Geelong has a bye.

Backs :   S.Fisher, B.Goddard, B.Deledio               Subs: A.Otten, N.Lower, M.Hibberd
             H.Shaw, M.Suckling, H.Taylor, B.Murphy   

Midfield:  S.Pendlebury, C.Judd, M.Boyd               Subs: S.Buckley, I.Smith, S.Atley
             M.Priddis, J.Kennedy, D.Swallow 

Ruck:      D.Cox, R.Warnock                               Subs: Z.Smith, M.Bailey

Fowards: L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, A.Goodes
             C.Sylvia, P.Chapman, Petrie, J.Riewoldt   Subs: T.Mzungu, D.Talia, J.Howe

I have 4 more trades with 78,000 in the bank, i want to immedietely get rid of Shaw (obviously) and that will either mean directly trading him to either Newman or Waters OR i would downsize him so i could upgrade Riewoldt and Swallow.

Thoughts? and Thanks

[ben_020285]

Shaw to Newman and then sit tight with 3 trades for finals.

[charliesheen]

You've got very good bench cover.  I would be inclined to grab Callinan (should be named this week), and upgrade D. Swallow to a premium mid fielder.  I reckon this will increase your scoring potential way more than playing David Swallow every week, and having a premium defender to replace shaw.  Ablett should get cheaper if you can wait.

When it comes close to finals, then sideways Heath Shaw/

[dons95]

thank you both for your replies.

i think im more inclined to downsize someone to callinan and upgrade swallow, because i can switch bob murphy from fwd to back and i have very good backline cover.

but i think i might want those 3 trades, depends whether i think i should hold onto petrie and judd (im thinking i should)
what do you guys think, keep petrie and judd?