Goldstein and Petrie issue

Started by LEV, June 28, 2011, 02:28:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

LEV

just a quick question, what are peoples thoughts how goldsteins and petries roles/games will change once macintosh returns? (he's not far away, maybe 3 - 4 weeks according to quote in artice - “He will be a great asset to us in the next few weeks before he gets called back up to the seniors. There’s no doubt today was only a sign that he’s only going to get better and better.”)

http://www.kangaroos.com.au/latestnews/newsarticle/tabid/4912/newsid/117166/default.aspx

I have to trade out sandi this week and was looking at either petrie or goldstein (prob petrie), but not so sure now if hmac comes in. 

Ziplock

Goldsteins scoring will be depreciated- Hmac will be stealing some of his hitout points. Could decrease him as much from a 100 avg to an 80 avg. Means he'll be spending more time forward, which would be ok... except apparently he can't kick very well.

Shouldn't affect petrie- I'm pretty sure he's averaging less than 1 HO per game this year- he's been playing as a tall forward aye?

lasonjin

Quote from: Ziplock on June 28, 2011, 02:47:57 PM
Goldsteins scoring will be depreciated- Hmac will be stealing some of his hitout points. Could decrease him as much from a 100 avg to an 80 avg. Means he'll be spending more time forward, which would be ok... except apparently he can't kick very well.

Shouldn't affect petrie- I'm pretty sure he's averaging less than 1 HO per game this year- he's been playing as a tall forward aye?

Pretty much this. Will affect Goldstein's time in the ruck, but shouldn't touch Petrie's (who's being playing as key tall forward). At most Petrie might drop a point or so.

thatguy

may even help petrie... with another tall fwd would stretch most defensive lines.

Jake8

i got goldy for sandi i dont know if it was a bad choice