Best defense players UG

[chappo44]

So i'm having a little trouble with my defense. It is pretty good now but I'm not sure who to upgrade too. I've cut it down to these defenders and why I think they will be a good/bad pick
Suckling- avg. 93.6     Plays GC twice, plays relatively easy teams, 1 bye remaining
Birchall- avg. 90.3       Plays GC twice, plays relatively easy teams, 1 bye remaining
Shaw- avg. 93.1        Will finish bye and I can bring him in next week, Can get tagged out of it
Fisher- 89.4              Bye out of way next week, Only plays a few decent teams, Potentail hard run through finals
Scotland- 99.2          Bye during finals- will be too hard to cover with 2 other carlton player so cant really fit him in structure

So the top 4 are the ones im considering, all about even as well.
Relating to DT which 2 players would be the best long term UG's. If i go shaw/fisher byes are out of way early, or I could go a hawks player for obvious reasons. While the averages dont reflect much they are handy to have. I might chose 1 of suckling or birch and then 1 of shaw or fisher.

Thoughts and suggestions. Thanks in advance.
*not interested in malceski*

[chaser]

Suckling. Reasonably cheap for his av. Reasonably consistant and has a huge ceiling

[Ago97]

For you my friend suckling is the best option

[thanme]

Why aren't you interested in Malceski, just out of curiosity??

Personally, I'll be picking up Shaw and Fisher after their respective byes. I know Shaw is a rollercoaster, but he's been killing it more often than not.

[chappo44]

Why aren't you interested in Malceski, just out of curiosity??

Personally, I'll be picking up Shaw and Fisher after their respective byes. I know Shaw is a rollercoaster, but he's been killing it more often than not.

Not a fan, too many injuries but then again some of my other choices have been injury prone players. only played 2 full seasons.

[thatguy]

Suckling. Reasonably cheap for his av. Reasonably consistant and has a huge ceiling

hawks love the ball in his hands too