Main Menu

how many cats is too many?

Started by DG, May 26, 2011, 03:09:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

DG

i currently have 2 cats (selwood and stevie j) is it worth getting another cat in this week (chappy) considering the finals bye, or worth taking a punt and hope that i win in week one? Or will it be an advantage to have to make less trades come finals?

Swallow12


4820

I would't bring in chappy this week. If you find yourself playing wk 2 of the finals you could have an issue on your hands. Who knows what will happen between now and the end of te season with trades. You may be low on trades. I would bring in someone if possible, that isn't affected by byes in finals. Consider chappy after week 2 of finals imo.   

Ziplock

Chappy may be the player to pull you over the line. Will you almost definitely finish top 4? Because if so, it might be worth it. From memory, Cats play Adelaide rd 21, I can see all three of those players comfortably pulling out scores between 120 and 140.

Risky though. I probably wouldn't do it.

m-ry

GO FOR GOLD BUDDY
if your def finishing in top 4
im currently sitting 8th in my league winner takes all ($800) and would be doing that if i was going to be top 4.
1 win between 4th and 12th. 2 wins between 1st and 12th 
13th and 14th only 2 win from 4th
so ill find out if i am in a couple of weeks

DG

yeah im currently top, but is a tough league, should finish top 4. worried if i dont get him ill be at disadvantage in first round of finals. i think whatever im thinking at 6 tomorrow will be the decision!

SydneyRox

I have three but only one in each area, Enright, Bartel and Chappy

Three isnt an issue IMO even if two in one spot and you have decent cover.

Bak2Form

i have enright,selwood,stevie j and adding in chapman this week, high risk equals reward, im going all out attack and getting them. Very Confident will make top 4, taking the punt on winning the 1st final. Dont know if its the right thing todo but im going for it

ShaynoB

Quote from: Bak2Form on May 26, 2011, 04:32:50 PM
i have enright,selwood,stevie j and adding in chapman this week, high risk equals reward, im going all out attack and getting them. Very Confident will make top 4, taking the punt on winning the 1st final. Dont know if its the right thing todo but im going for it

+1 except don't have Enright.

Windigo

I only have Stevie J........I'm looking at getting Chappy next week.

But I have no swans players at the moment and the only swan I would have would Goodes.

I would have like $ 120,000+ for a Deledio trade in in 2 weeks if I get Goodes.  ???

Wes Mantooth

i hope no one got chappy yet!

the only amount of cats thats too many, is those you cant cover but i think 3 is fine, in dif positions preferably

PowerBug

Worth the punt, but not this week.