Who to play on the field in defence?

[fidou]

I have a tough choice playing only one of these players in defence? Will Hibberd play? Jacobs on the bench v Carlton, Duigan v PA, Lower hard match against the Hawks, Buckley v StK.

[SydneyRox]

Lower is my choice, even though he is playing the hawks in Melb.

The 'sensible' pick is probably Duigan vs Port who should get hammered by the Blues

[JT23]

hibberd for sure

[PowerBug]

Jacobs.

[muggle25]

Hibberd: from 3 games scores 68, 72, 80. Consistent. Against Melb.
Stanley: in form, should be on thee ground
Duigan: struggles in the wet and it will be wet in adelaide.  Is from Adelaide so will feel at home.
Lower: consistent scores, second interstate trip in 3 weeks, will this have an efeect?

My order of preference: Stanley, Hibberd, Lower, Duigan

[Ziplock]

^ pretty close to my order as well. Stanley super consistent, melbourne give away huge points to the mids/ defence, so they both rate high. Lower and duigan's inconsistency puts me off them.

:-X

[fran]

I have a bad feeling Hibberd will be the sub... At least since there the first game you can always take him off your field just before lockout if it happens