Fyfe or Silvia as a trade in for McKernan???

[Brocky101]

which one would u trade in... for Mckernan

[dicey7]

Im in a similar situation but insteads its either fyfe or chappy.

I like fyfe myself, both sylvia and fyfe have the bye in the same round (multi bye 16)

Sylvia can pump out huge scores but also some sub 80 ones, also melb arent travelling too well

but fyfes shouder has looked very sore recently

[LF]

sylvia
91,98,75,132,90,149,96,96 and this week 100
chappy
101,100,120,130,76,83,110 and this week 95
fyfe
95,65,117,137,107,69,114,120 and this week 80

[LaHug]

Sylvia. More proven and scores well when Melbourne loses. Just imagine if they win one :o

[Brocky101]

i already have chappy, but  its either silvia, or fyfe just stuck on the choice

[Jukes]

Sylvia the Chappy then Fyfe. Fyfe is very inconsistent, and Chappy is bald... I have Sylvia and Chappy and both have been good so far, Sylvia has been a gun all year.

[yorgis]

anyone he's a dud spud