Captain please

Started by tony73, June 06, 2009, 05:03:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who???

Swan
6 (35.3%)
Judd
3 (17.6%)
Selwood
5 (29.4%)
Bartell
3 (17.6%)

Total Members Voted: 2

tony73

Leaning towards the in form Swan against Dees or Judd good record against Lions

Cant help but think Bartell is due but he has not averaged well at Subi

My opponent has gone with Selwood

gerco

I'd go Swanny.

Judd's great record against the Lions was with Cuz, Kerr and Fletcher in the side with him, although against some great Lions sides.

Bartel has always played well against the Eagles, but not always at Subiaco.

I'd go with Dane Swan, but be prepared for one of the other 2 (whoever you pick) to put up great numbers and make you pull your hair out.

yeahsup

ablett:p

nah outa them not sure bout swan.. not a sc'er.  judd to me.

Dees for the Draft

I'd be tempted to go Selwood or Bartel.

Both are capable of putting up big SC scores, where as Swan isn't a guarantee of a big SC score.

I had Bartel as captain two weeks ago, when he put up a 184 in SC, compared to a 139 in DT.

Of those 4, I'd probably go Barlet because he's got more of a history of big scores.