Better JS Puopolo or Isaac Smith

[Ziplock]

mmm, not for me, because like a horrible DTer, I traded in hibberd + jacobs before they were on the bubble. Bad ziplock.

however, this does enable me to get in smith and puopolo this week ;)

although, I mighten't go smith tbh, as hawks bye in rd 17 could screw me with rioli and franklin.

[elephants]

Remember that smith is mpp zip :)

[HTL]

Both look like great options. I'm leaning towards Puopolo atm only because I need more cover in my back line.

[Ziplock]

Remember that smith is mpp zip :)

I know, even then I think it would be tight, I don't really have any players worth downgrading at this point in my mids, if higgins is out again though, I will drop his sorry ass in a heart beat. flowering asshole.

but yeah, my midfield non keepers atm have the following BEs

88 for cotchin (who's averaging 90), but unfortunately I see him as an upgrade target rather than downgrade (downgrading to smith would weaken my mids far too much)
17 for ward
35 for libba
21 for Harris
and -67 for hibberd :P

[joshas182]

poo, hibberd or jacobs...

that is the question this week for lots of us......

Yes this is true...picked up Jacobs last week in the midfield for his MPP (and Hibberd wasn't named at the time) but needing/wanting to get rid of Toy this week.
Leaning more towards Pop as only have Franklin so far and Hibberd has the bye in the DT GF and I already have 2 Don's already!
Also, with this downgrade...was going to upgrade Harris in the midfield for Sylvia (MPP)...is this a good idea? With 20 trades left and $164k in the bank and having to offload Curnow and Grimes last week, is this a good idea? Or too many trades too early?

[Ziplock]

I would do the harris trade, but only if you were then going to swap sylvia into your forward line with dpp, and bench a rookie in his place. If not, he's not quite averaging enough for a mid, and it looks like he should really be placed in the fwds for that extra bolster of points.

Is there another option other than harris? he still has some solid cash to make.

[joshas182]

Yes Ziplock, exactly what I was planning...but now looking at Fyfe now instead...