Curnow-smith. Swallow/hariss - ?

Started by pardz, May 17, 2011, 09:50:57 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to get ?

Joel selwood
9 (900%)
sam Mitchell
6 (600%)
Marc Murphy
2 (200%)
Scott Thompson
6 (600%)
Leigh montagna
1 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Voting closed: May 24, 2011, 11:23:32 AM

pardz

Who should I upgrade swallow or Harris to ? Already have Boyd pendles and swan . I'm leaning towards j selwood but s Thompson looks good but I'm not sure how long he's injured for. What are your thoughts ?

Ziplock

league or overall, how many cats in your team,

Swallow has a higher BE, already costs more (therefor has less cash to make), although they are averaging relatively similar. I would be looking at offloading him first.

Selwood for me, unless you are going purely for league and already have chapman and enright, or stevie J etc. etc.

pardz

I only have enright from Geelong so i am probably looking at selwood then Scott Thompson thoughts ?

Ziplock


LaHug

Selwood without a doubt. Proven gun. Scoring higher this year (especially if you take out the concussion game). Scott Thompson looks great as a semi-unique though.

pardz

Yer I agree Scott Thompson looks good also