Mundy or Redden

Started by Nails, May 05, 2011, 09:46:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one should I get in my side? Who will avg more?

Mundy
8 (66.7%)
Redden (will give me 2 Lions in the mids)
4 (33.3%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Nails

Getting Libba out for one of these two...

Redden = hasn't really smashed a good team yet... did get 112 against Freo though

Mundy = only plays GC once haha. Should be the only Docker in my mids, therefore giving me less bye issues for my mids. I can't really split these two.

The second I think I'm going Mundy I then think I want Redden because he's 16k less :(

Windigo

Just traded Redden in. You don't bust 130's for nothing.

He tackles a lot too. Which will help Vs better teams....I hope.  ???

Nails

Yeah, I always forget the tackling!

I think I might get Redden in this week, simply for the fact he has a lower BE. Therefore if Mundy knocks out another 100+ score next week he won't rise as much as Redden will when he scores 172 vs GC (haha)

Will have a problem if Foley keeps knocking out 100+ scores though... Rockliff, Redden and Foley all out in rd19 (from my mids)

With Goodes in fwds and Delids in back... Will probably traded Foley out by then so 4 players out isn't too bad. I think I'll just chuck Redden in.

Rockliff, Redden and Mundy will give me a great unique midfield with the ability to make or break my team... fffff dunno how I'm going to get Boyd/Watson/Mitchell in now though.

Harry_West

Get redden for sure and put the big C on him too

Nails

I pulled the trigger on the Red dawg. Now my biggest issue is...

Rockliff OR Redden for captain...

Redden has outscored Rockliff against the tougher teams, but Rockliff has outscored Redden against the rubbish teams.

Therefore I think I'll Rockliff C, Redden VC.

Nails

Should have gone Mundy :(  :'(

Windigo

QuoteShould have gone Mundy :(  :'(

Collective BUGGER.

Double BUGGER if you C'ed him.  ::)

Nails

Quote from: Windigo on May 07, 2011, 09:55:24 PM
QuoteShould have gone Mundy :(  :'(

Collective BUGGER.

Double BUGGER if you C'ed him.  ::)

You go Redden over Mundy because of the lower BE thinking Redden will be worth a lot more $$$$...

Little did you know he's hardly going to reach his pathetic Be...