Enright or Chapman

[Memphistopheles]

Pretty straightforward.

Enright has a lower BE than Chapman, but Chappy is a higher scorer (usually) than Enright.

I'm not sure how exact these numbers are as I don't have ass coach, but i am getting Enright's BE at 99 and Chapmans at 111.

I'm thinking of getting both, but can only afford one this week (would have to do a double trade to get either).

Who should it be?

[Ziplock]

I thought enrights BE was around high 80s?


post your backline and fwd line (I presume you want chappy in fwds) and we'll help out :)

[Memphistopheles]

Enright would complete my backline.

Backs: God, Gibbs, Lids, Grimey, Adcock, Heppell, Lower, Otten, Stanley, Toy.

(Heppell a keeper, with Lower a good sub). Otten to go for Enright obviously.

Mids: Swan, Selwood, Boyd, Foley, Swallow, Libba, Harris, Hibberd, Prestia

Forwards: Pavlich, Goodes, Franklin, Riewoldt, Riewoldt, Petrie, Knights, Darling, Matera, Krakouer.

Chapman could be a mid or forward.

The BE's were taken from footywire so may not be accurate.

[Ziplock]

you must be pretty decently ranked, that's quite a nice team. Holding off trades could be worthwhile for you, just give those cash cows a little longer to mature. That being said, Otten would be a reasonable choice to go, and maybe toy/stanley (pick whoever isn't named) down to jacobs?

then upgrade otten to enright if you have the cash.

[Memphistopheles]

you must be pretty decently ranked, that's quite a nice team. Holding off trades could be worthwhile for you, just give those cash cows a little longer to mature. That being said, Otten would be a reasonable choice to go, and maybe toy/stanley (pick whoever isn't named) down to jacobs?

then upgrade otten to enright if you have the cash.

The problem is I am not decently ranked, mainly due to poor bench choices. Currently at ~9000

And my goal is overall. Not so much to win the car, but to beat a mate (he's up by 200 points atm).

Am about 20,000 short of the enright trade if I go Stanley to Jacobs.

I could hold off trading and wait for the cows to increase. But, if I do this Enright and Chappy will also go up in value so its a win/lose situation.

Which is why I am asking for help.

I'm leaning towards Enright as he will complete my backs and then I can let Lower, Stanley and Toy gain bit of cash on the bench while possible downgrade options (Puopolo, Jacobs etc) get matchtime and reach the cusp. Then I will use that cash to bolster the mids and forwards.

My only concern is that Chappy seems to be the best-performing forward and I don't want to miss out on too many of his scores.

[Ziplock]

I wouldn't bet on enright going up in value this week, or not by much, and as their prices are much closer to their averages than most CC's, the amount they go up will be substantially less.

[Memphistopheles]

I might hold off for a week then on trading and wait till a cow is ready to harvest and do the Otten ---> Enright trade.

Only other trade would be to get in Wallis or Iles, but can't see where with this team.