fyfe upgrade for knights or d swallow?

[lukedogg17]

looking to insert fyfe this week at a reasonable price while i can, swallow looks to be plateauing in price with a b/e of 45 this week. got krak in the mids and higgins in fwds both mpp. knights is currently my 7th fwd and im a bit light in the mids so probably going to upgrade swallow at this point rather than knights, thoughts?

[TheHanger]

neither, you dont have anyone worse than swallow? he averaging about 80, good even if he aint skyrocketing in price everyweek so maybe someone else besides him. Knights as well looks to good to trade out

[lukedogg17]

harris mckenzie libba, but only got 116 sitting in the bank so unable to upgrade them in the one hit, thats whats appealing to me, one trade upgrade for either two

[CuStArDaRm]

too early to trade those 2 trade someone else

[TheHanger]

im going with Harris out maybe this week. probably for fyfe but maybe Redden

[Slap]

keep harris over swallow..  Unless your planning on keeping one.

Harris stared 50k less and has 50k more to be made at the same average at least..  (compared to Swallow), but If I had to keep one as bench cover permanently, I'd rather Swallow than Harris.

[TheHanger]

keep harris over swallow..  Unless your planning on keeping one.

i assume you mean for the whole year? i just think Harris doesnt have the X Factor that swallow does, like a 50 point quarter. also Swallow will improve exponentially over the season while Harris will not

[lukedogg17]

too early to cash in on libba? problem ive got is swan pendles dawes krak out and then next wk 4 carlton players out and i need to keep in touch with the league, no point saving my trades for later if i dont even make it lol

[Slap]

keep harris over swallow..  Unless your planning on keeping one.

i assume you mean for the whole year? i just think Harris doesnt have the X Factor that swallow does, like a 50 point quarter. also Swallow will improve exponentially over the season while Harris will not

Na man.

I said keep harris over Swallow if your gonna cash em both.  'Unless your planning on keeping one' - then you'd take Swallow; for the reasons you suggested.

[Ziplock]

I wouldn't say exponentially. Harris and swallow both have close to the same scoring potential, and job security, swallow maybe ahead on scoring potential. However, neither are really mid keepers atm, except maybe on the bench, while harris has more price to rise than swallow atm.

[Windigo]

Just had geez on who Fyfe actually played against Brisband, Geelong, Adelaide, North & the Dogs.

He scored only 60 odd Vs the cats.....

As for Redden I'm all over him but once again I've been shut down and how he won't continue to amass big numbers...... ???

[Master Q]

Don't get too excited about Fyfe.