1 trade and 1 trade only

[craig22]

im gonna make 1 trade this week, im thinking of going from col sylvia to dustin martin. Good call Bad call?

[MarkPlow]

bad call

[craig22]

bad call

why?

[MarkPlow]

Martin has smashed it against Kangaroos and Brisbane. Very good player but so is Sylvia. Martin will still bust out high scores but Sylvia is just as likely. Waste of a trade in my opinion.

[ben_ess94]

Martin has smashed it against Kangaroos and Brisbane. Very good player but so is Sylvia. Martin will still bust out high scores but Sylvia is just as likely. Waste of a trade in my opinion.

+1
sideways. sylvia suffeed as all of melbourne did last week.
missed the boat on martin

[roo boys!]

Don't do it, keep Sylvia.

I wish we could use 22 trades at a time....need a whole new team after this week...

[craig22]

I wish we could use 22 trades at a time....need a whole new team after this week...

+1

[roo boys!]

I wish we could use 22 trades at a time....need a whole new team after this week...

+1

Looking at 1800 >:(

[craig22]

its gonna be a low week with everyone i need swan as captain ta boost me up today hopefuuly him and pendles kill

[newfreofan]

Terrible trade, Sylvia is a keeper, especially if you're looking for league results. Demons have a great 4 games for the finals and their 2nd bye isn't a league game. I'm looking at picking up Sylvia mid season, hopefully close to a straight swap with Tapscott if he comes back into form.

[bottlemart]

Bad Call.  Extremely Sideways Call. 

Isn't Colin Sylvia averaging nearly 100 and is MPP.  He must have either some season ending LTI that you know about and we don't, or you just don't value your trades.

I would Keep Sylvia.

But, your team, not mine, so if ya wanna do it, go ahead.

[JimMundy93]

i agree with everyone here
massive sideways trade