Otten for Hibberd or Thompson?

[oldshepp]

Hi Guys

First time I'm looking at trading this year

My plan is Otten (who I have never started on field) for either Hibberd (who I was surprised I hadn't picked pre-season) or Thompson from Adelaide.  The boy from Timboon looks likely and might have better js than I thought

Hibberd would be handy with the MPP with Heppell

This trade has to happen because the bigger picture for me is Krak to JRoo.

Thoughts please?

(I don't know how to start a poll so your thoughts would be appreciated)

[Chopps]

hibberd's first game yea i wouldnt trade in not knowing his ability at afl level

[BratPack]

Hibberd. Thompson is a SC prototype. But if you have cover I'd keep Otten for a week or two. I don't see him being out for long and Hibberd isn't on the bubble yet.

[oldshepp]

Thanks for the early replies

I've just had a second look and it seems JRoo might be a SC prototype forward too with a pretty ordinary DT average

Might move the question over to SC section and hang on to my 24 trades then   :D