(IT INVOLVES HARRY TAYLOR) you'd have to be a genius to figure it out!!!

Madsnake · April 20, 2011, 10:16:54 PM

okay so i have a little problem deciding what to do with bloody harry taylor. take a look at my situation and see if you can work out something for me to do...

DEF: Bryce Gibbs(DPP), Dyson Heppell(DPP), Brendon Goddard(DPP), Jason Gram, Cameron Bruce, Nick Duigan, Harry Taylor (subs: Jack Grimes (subbed due to melbourne having the bye), Danny Stanley, Nick Lower)

i have alot of depth in the defence with lower most likely back in this week and apart from grimes all of my other players are playing. i also have simon buckley in the mid as a link between def-mid, having this much depth leans me towards keeping him.... but at the moment he is just plummeting in price so i am unsure whether to trade taylor for a premium/mid-pricer, trade him to a rookie like brodie smith or josh toy to make some cash or just stick with him on the bench and hope he gets better (seeing as i do have enough cover for that)... bit longwinded and mindbottling but what do you dreamteam overlords think about this one?

ShaynoB · April 20, 2011, 10:34:15 PM

I'd get rid of him now. Out of the next 4 weeks he has 3 pretty challenging teams to play so cant see him leaving the key backman to get easy kicks to often. He also has a very high BE this week so yeah....

Remove him and keep the $$ unless u have another area which you can upgrade

Windigo · April 20, 2011, 10:38:13 PM

Get rid of him.

Is never near the ball.

hardnut · April 20, 2011, 10:39:25 PM

cut him loose..I'd probably get Toy given GCS defender issues and pocket the $$'s for upgrades. Taylor was never likely to be a keeper so chalk that one down as a risk that didn't work (as I did with Foley) and move on.

Ziplock · April 20, 2011, 10:43:27 PM

Drop him. He's a mid pricer, you only get them in for 2 reasons
1. they may end up being a keeper
2. they will gain enough cash to be able to straight swap to a fallen premium
taylor's just leaking cash atm, fulfilling neither of those cases, so he has to go.

your backline is pretty over powered in my opinion anyway, you can easily afford dropping him to a rookie. Toy is by far the best option currently.

Madsnake · April 20, 2011, 10:49:29 PM

looks like i'm gonna drop him, although i don't know if toy s the best option for me. i already have Prestia, Matera, Harris, smith and stanley in my side so could be too many GCers as valuable as they are. maybe brodie smith or cam pederson if he makes the side... any other good options?

Windigo · April 20, 2011, 10:52:58 PM

Every seems to want Toy.

It seems McKenna makes him where the green vest. It's probably in his wardrobe at his home. :P

hardnut · April 20, 2011, 10:54:33 PM

just being worked into the AFL, clearly talented and able to put a score on the board. I don't have him but if Lower isn't named I might jump on!

Ziplock · April 20, 2011, 10:56:55 PM

by GC's second bye players like matera and stanley will probably already be out of your team anyway, Z smith and harris may stay as potential bench keepers and prestia possibly for mpp purposes. I only bring up toy because he's a fair bit cheaper the B Smith.

Fenno · April 21, 2011, 10:43:17 AM

Quote from: Windigo on April 20, 2011, 10:52:58 PM
Every seems to want Toy.

It seems McKenna makes him where the green vest. It's probably in his wardrobe at his home. :P

He wore it once. Unless your one of the stars in a team most players during the season will have a go at wearing a vest at some time during the year.

Master Q · April 21, 2011, 11:08:33 AM

Get rid of him.

Montag · April 21, 2011, 07:33:25 PM

NOOOOOOOO
I THINK IM TOO LATE. HE IS PLAYING HAWKS THIS WEEK WITH FRANKLIN ROUGHEAD. HE WILL PLAY ON ONE OF THEM AND SHOULD GET A GOOD SCORE. WHEN HE PLAYS GOOD TEAMS HE SCORES HIGH, shower TEAMS HE SCORES LOW. HES A DEFENDER. WHEN THEY PLAY A GOOD TEAM THE BALL IS IN DEFENCE MORE. ILL GARUNTEE YOU HE WILL GET 80+

(IT INVOLVES HARRY TAYLOR) you'd have to be a genius to figure it out!!!

Montag