krakouer to libba OR broughton to adcock??? AARGGHHH!

[sledgey7]

having to trade coad to toy this week and also want to do one of the above trades.

have only used 1 trade so far this year.

backline is grimes, lake, duigan, goddard, heppell, broughton, lower (otten, hibberd, coad)

midfield is swan, boyd, joey, pav, gibbs, swallow (harris, kraka, atley)

Has the libba boat sailed? i tend to think not seeing as a lot of us paid even more for swallow at the start of the season hoping he'd avg 80 (which he is) and libba is now averaging nearly 90.

would the broughton to adcock trade be too much of a sideways with not enough gain, with the possibility of broughton running hot, adcock going cold/getting injured too great?

whichever trade i choose to complete, the other will be lost in the annuls of history.

HELP ME DECIDE!!!!

[Ziplock]

if you think broughts can return to his previous premium status, keep him. If not, trade him. Personally I don't think he can, wit his role change, but w.e

[j959]

i vote against Broughton to Adcock because of the potential inj risks - effectively you're downgrading last year's premium who's down on form (or possibly a role change) to a (now) mid-pricer who is a returning LTI (though you could possibly view him as fallen 'premium').

i like libba jnr but can you upgrade Kraks instead - might also be patient and wait til Kraks has hit his value earning ceiling??

[Master Q]

Broughton to Adcock

[Vortex08]

I'm thinking Broughton to Gram for me - better (injury) security. Anyone's thoughts?

[C-Dogg]

broughton to enright if need be, but im keeping gregy boy

[fortynine]

I would go with Enright or Gram personally, much more stability in selection and roles

[Windigo]

At the start of the year I would have tipped Broughton to outscore Adcock.

SO based on that. If you HAVE to trade, then Broughton>Enright is a much bette deal.

You just don't no what Adcock's gunna do.

He will get you 80's no sweat. But he gets injured.....