Inspired move or just plain stupid ??

[nostradamus]

l am considering (depending on squad named) trading coad to hibberd instead of toy

My reasoning is:

1. l have alot of good cash cows in the paddock
2. l want an extra mpp link to mids so l can use heppell in defence
3. Think hibbo will be dempseys replacement down back
4. Dont want to use another trade getting him in if l do get toy

.....am just unsure whether l'll pull the trigger on this madness this week...........finger.......is ..........itchy
.....or whether l will/can hold of until next week

Can somebody give me a dose of common sense please, and bring some clarity to my addled thoughts

[Ziplock]

trade to toy... we don't know hibberds JS is any good, or his AFL scoring potential.

However, we know toy has good job security, he scored 75 last week, and 50 in a half of afl. So he's got decent scoring potential was well....

[Fenno]

I would say go for Toy even if Hibberd is named. By the time Hibberd is on the bubble one of your other rookies would have peaked so you can get him in for them then.

[CFC 1979]

sound thinking..............................

scratch that finger
wait for teams to be named
if you have mpp already you don't need hibberd yet
check toy's BE and cash making ability
and .................................................

scratch that finger

[nostradamus]

sound thinking..............................

scratch that finger
wait for teams to be named
if you have mpp already you don't need hibberd yet
check toy's BE and cash making ability
and .................................................

scratch that finger

have heppell in mids and gibbs, godd and dids down back

[CFC 1979]

hows the itch ?

[nostradamus]

hows the itch ?

words of wisdom from you, fenno and zip have definately put some clarity in my thinking

......but......the.......itch......is.......still........there  :o

[bundyboy]

wait.....just no point in hibberd this week....  -  his price won't change for 2 weeks anyway even if named, so plenty of time to make that decision...

[nostradamus]

thx for the advice boys, its decided will trade toy in.......unless not picked of course. Then trade hibberd in when he's on the bubble and one of my cows is nice and fat  ;)

[Windigo]

Hibbo must surely be selected sometime  in the next month.

But remember, he has only played limited games. As if Hird would select him without a few more BOG performances.

It'll happen he won the Fothergill medal last year.

[nostradamus]

Hibbo must surely be selected sometime  in the next month.

But remember, he has only played limited games. As if Hird would select him without a few more BOG performances.

It'll happen he won the Fothergill medal last year.

same award that barlow won the year before wasn't it?

[Windigo]

Yeah. Is it a sign....? :o

[nostradamus]

hope so....but will there ever be another barlow??