Broughton dilemma!!!

[mote]

just a simple yes or no answer and then maybe let me know who you think i should trade him to if you think he has to go.
cheers

[Davoo]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,32582.0.html

[hally25547]

cull him. he is playing a new defensive role this year and he is playing it well which is good for freo but bad for us dt coaches that have him

[mote]

im leaning towards keeping him cos silvagni and others are coming back in who can play his defensive role, which will hopefully release him into his old role which he scores far better. adcocks my only other real option and im not sure if he can keep up his good start to the year

[yorgis]

i'm prepared to give he and duffs 1 more week, then they have the bye. their B/E's are high considering what they have been scoring, and they will prolly lose a bit. don't really want to downgrade to a rookie. i'd rather downgrade a cash cow to a rookie and upgrade him to a more prem defender, but as yet none of them have made enough. just hope that broughts don't lose too much

[Slap]

i'm prepared to give he and duffs 1 more week, then they have the bye. their B/E's are high considering what they have been scoring, and they will prolly lose a bit. don't really want to downgrade to a rookie. i'd rather downgrade a cash cow to a rookie and upgrade him to a more prem defender, but as yet none of them have made enough. just hope that broughts don't lose too much

Thats the problem though Yorgis, he will lose a lot.  Its a matter of biting the bullet and saving money.  Or holding the faith for most of the season (for better or for worse).