FLIP duff out FLOP duff in FLIP duff out FLOP duff in aaaarrrrrrggggg!!!!

Started by nostradamus, April 19, 2011, 11:42:56 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

nostradamus

Well fellas l'm going a bit crazy here, duffman is doing my head in!! Commonsense tells me to show faith, but......

with the defensive push on everywhere this year alot of backline players roles have changed.

Reasons for trading out:
1. He's been a DUD this year, my lowest averaging defender
2. Should trade before his value goes even lower
3. Do the trade before other players value goes up (double the difference there if duff goes down again)
4. He is p!ssing me off

Reasons for keeping:
1. Picked him for a reason....show faith
2. Proven performer over the years, will come good
3. With suban out duffs role may change
4. Am concerned Adcocks(probable trade target) role will change when drummond comes back

Any thoughts or input greatlly appreciated by bloke running around in circles  :-\


tappy21

got the same issue. decided im gonna stick with him. reason being i paid 360ish or watever it was for him so not prepared to just cop a loss on a guy that can score big. it is only round 4! ill upgrade around him i reckon. get some rookies out, better prem defenders in and the composition of the back 7 will look ok with him still in there.

Windigo

Duff's role was the rebounding defender.

I haven't watched any Freo games so I don't know if his role has changed or just is not getting enough space..

elephants

If he can knock his average up to 80 odd I will accept him as a 7th back. Not pleased with him at all. Gram look very good but I am waiting a couple of weeks for him.