What is the better trade?

[fran]

hey guys,

I am looking to get in one or both of libratore and curnow. I dont have enough money to sidewards trade so im going to have to double trade to get them in.

Option one would give me both curnow + libba but im worried that D.Swallow could improve lots on his score from lastweek and leave me regretting the decision.

Option two involves trading moran (97k) to mccauly (80k) to raise enough cash to go from irons -> libratore (or curnow). Im not too worried abut mccauly's job security or his scoring as i would always play smith over him when cox/sandilands have the bye.

what are your sugguestions?

[boo-yaa]

i wouldn't drop the number 1 draft pick after just one game personally.

[Generalsor]

i wouldn't drop the number 1 draft pick after just one game personally.

+1

[Nails]

Both rubbish trades IMO.

[Slap]

Not stupid, but two trades down.. if you think you'll get 200k or more from this trade than what you'd earn with Irons/Moran, do it. 

Sure it'd be awesome to have the excitement of both libba and Curnow, but its not essential.

[soutter]

Both rubbish trades IMO.

+1

[boo-yaa]

you pay the extra cash for swallows job security, he will play every week.
the same can't be said for libba and curnow.

[yorgis]

oh soooooo troooo booooyaaaaa

[fran]

got out moran and irons and got in libratore and got in mccauly. i know mccauly isnt named but i doubt i'd ever play him anyway. think i will make much more cash this way.

[boo-yaa]

oh dear. why would you trade for mccauley, he won't play much unless there are injurys.
try save your trades, they are priceless at the end of the year.