foley...

[froggy74]

ok thank you for the advice ill def keep hibbert then, do u think libba is better to get in then curnow?

[beermee]

trade foley to c.young

[froggy74]

i dont have enough for a straight swap if i did have enough i would considerate it, libba or curnow?

[Slap]

i dont have enough for a straight swap if i did have enough i would considerate it, libba or curnow?

get some money for foley, libba and curnow are holding there own aswell atm. 

Either one is a good pick.  I personally think the Carlton emergencies are better tahn the Bulldogs emergencies atm..  But whether that means you'd pick Libba > Curnow, who knows.  I think Carlton's lineup over the next 6 weeks is marginaly better than the Dogs, does that mean Curnow. 

I just like how Curnow moves.  He also admitted in an article that he recognises taht he NEEDS to perform each week to stay in the interchangeable carlton mids.  So, whether that means like he will be playing for his life each week..

No one knows, Curnow has a bigger body than Libba.  And an earlier rest (bye), so whether taht means he'd avoid being a sub - who knows.  At the beginning of the week, I'd have said Curnow, but after reading some things about Libba, its balanced out.

But if I was in a position to trade either in, I'd pick Curnow.