Liam Anthony > Curnow

[swanny89]

I've heard a few people recommend selling Anthony with his lack of time on ground. The guy's a point machine, and surely he won't get the vest too often if at all... Just after some reassurance that I'm doing the right thing by holding on to him.

I already have Liberatore, but missed Curnow so the only thought would be to downgrade to him to make some cash. Only other options to pick up Curnow are Kerr or Conca. But I'm thinking I hold steady and save the trade. Thoughts?

[Mish]

i got anthony as a pottential keeper, as a kangas member i was very angry seing anthony in a green vest and so were many other supporters, members and DT coaches. i really cant see him sitting on the bench again, atley isnt ready for AFL imo.

also even with the vest anthony came on and got 64 in 1 half, the guy is a ball magnate. keep him, i havent even considered getting rid of him, especially to a rookie.

if you really wana get rid of coz you just personally hate him than maybe look at getting someone like palmer or cotchin.

[swanny89]

No, I picked him as a keeper too. As long as he gets game time I'm sure he'll dominate, just wanted some other opinions on whether Scott will make the same ridiculous decision he did last week.

[Mish]

i dont think scotty will make the same silly mistake as he did last week, it was just idiotic, collingwoods midfield tore us appart a lot worse than when anthony was in there.

maybe scotty knew we were going to get pumped and let a kid get some experience.

[Chopps]

keep anthony if he isnt a 100+ keeper he is a straight swap or good stepping stone to a premium