Petrie vs Tapscott

[popedelio]

Yes it seems like bazzare match up though the factors i'm looking at is who they are playing. NM vs COLL means that the ball is very likely not going to end up in the NM fwd line, and since petrie has changed roles to a Full Fwd might not get many DT points. Where as Tapscott plays a defensive midfield role, against hawthorn and should rack up close to the score he had last week.
Who do you think is going to have a better score?? Should I stick with the experienced Petrie or take the punt on youngTapscott?

[dale93]

Tapscott mate....

[Mish]

I dont agree, look at robbie gray and brogan, a forward and a ruck both got top 5 scorers for port adelaide against collingwood, and port got thumped!! not one defender even got over 74 for port and most defenders got below 60.
plus petrie will have a role in the ruck as HMAC is still injuired and goldstein isnt 100%.

i would allways go for experienced scorer over a rookie.