Rate and see how my team looks, need feedback

Started by Staggs, March 12, 2011, 08:33:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What do you rate my team?

10/10
1 (100%)
9/10
3 (300%)
8/10
1 (100%)
7/10
0 (0%)
generic as shower but will still do the job :P 8/10 +
1 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Staggs

DEF: B. Goddard (STK), B. Deledio (RICH), J. Grimes (MELB), G. Broughton (FREM), J. Adcock (BRIS), A. Otten (ADEL), D. Heppell (ESS) Bench: M. Coad (GC), P. Puopolo (HAW), N. Duigan (CARL)

MID: D. Swan (COLL), J. Selwood (GEEL), L. Hodge (HAW), L. Anthony (NM), B. Gibbs (CARL), D. Swallow (GC)
Bench: T. Mzungu (FREM)*, M. Hibberd (ESS), J. Polec (BRIS)**

RUCK: A. Sandilands (FREM), D. Petrie (NM) Bench: T. Derickx (RICH), Z. Smith (GC)

FOR: A. Didak (COLL), N. Riewoldt (STK), L. Franklin (HAW), M. Pavlich (FREM), A. Krakourer (COLL), M. Hurley (ESS), J. Darling (WCE)*** Bench: C. Richardson (NM), B. Matera (GC), I. Smith (HAW)

* - I know Tendai Mzungu is injured but I'm waiting to see what the extent of the injury is, got probably Shaun Atley or Mitch Wallis on stand by as a straight swap if he's out for an extensive period.

** - i swear this may be a never ending debate but Gaff, Polec or Conca? ahah

*** - my last forward spot will be rotated through Darling, Richardson, Matera + Smith depending on form, but is that really a viable option to be a successful dream teamer? bit concerned going into the season with Krakourer, Hurley + another rookie on the field week in week out.

Any feed back would be greatly appreciated.

Cheers

david.5

freaking awesome team. Yeah id go with conca and hodge hasnt had a preseason so you might want to consider someone else. Also haris is a definate lock, you need him in your side. Also round one rucks might be a problem since petrie is suspeded and smith has a bye.

Staggs

thanks for the feedback :)

i've heard the advice and settled for this side for now, open for feedback further still.

worth noting I have $28,500 cash remaining, so have a little bit of freedom in that department

DEF: B. Goddard (STK), B. Deledio (RICH), J. Grimes (MELB), G. Broughton (FREM), J. Adcock (BRIS), A. Otten (ADEL), D. Heppell (ESS) Bench: M. Coad (GC), P. Puopolo (HAW), N. Duigan (CARL)

MID: D. Swan (COLL), J. Selwood (GEEL), A. Didak (COLL), L. Anthony (NM), B. Gibbs (CARL), D. Swallow (GC)
Bench: D. Harris (GC), M. Hibberd (ESS), R. Conca (RICH)

RUCK: A. Sandilands (FREM), D. Petrie (NM) Bench: T. Derickx (RICH), Z. Smith (GC)

FOR: A. Goodes (SYD), N. Riewoldt (STK), L. Franklin (HAW), M. Pavlich (FREM), A. Krakourer (COLL), M. Hurley (ESS), J. Darling (WCE)*** Bench: T. Mzungu (FREM), B. Matera (GC), I. Smith (HAW)

cmgb84

didak has also had an injury interrupted pre season...  you obviously are after a strong midfield which is an interesting tactic as traditionally the best rooks come from there

a few suggestions

dids - m.murphy
conca - prestia

hugebbq


Staggs

the reason i've selected Didak is because he is the only player in my midfield who has Mid/For MPP status, is there any other Mid/For or straight Forwards that i can get for Didak and i'll reshuffle to have Goodes or Pavlich up the ground?