Goddard, Corey or Riewoldt???

Started by yogibbear, May 04, 2009, 09:57:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

If you could pick only 1, which one?

Joel Corey
0 (0%)
Nick Riewoldt
9 (42.9%)
Brendan Goddard
9 (42.9%)
Andrew Mackie
3 (14.3%)

Total Members Voted: 2

yogibbear

If you could pick only 1, which one?

Corey, Goddard, Riewoldt, Mackie?

Blueboys

Gee thats a big story! If you want trade advice keep it short and to the point.


yogibbear

#2
Edited original post so that it takes less than 10 seconds to read :P

Dees for the Draft

I wouldn't trade in Corey.  I'm not a fan of his new half-back role. 

Goddard is a gun, although Mackie may be a bargain as Harley is likely to come back this week, which may free him up a bit. 

Riewoldt is a gun, but he's got two massive scores in his rolling average, so you may find that he's better value in a couple of weeks if he doesn't keep up his awesome form.

Blueboys

easy, Goddard, I have had him since the start of the year and done very well. Keeper for sure.

If you want some extra cash get on Gilbert.

Either 1 will serve you well. hope that helps...

Chief Runs With Beer

Want a reliable, trustworthy champion? Nick Riewoldt.

Has been teasing 100 avg for consistent seasons now.

Brendon Goddard is flavour of the month material. His scores have been piggy-backed by this superbly in-form St Kilda side, and a their well-oiled machine in the back 50 (Geary, Gilbert, Ray, Blake, Dawson).

It's too easy to call Goddard the choice out of that quarter - but look at the bigger picture.

micklovin

goddard... purely coz prem. backs are harder to find

yogibbear

Well i went with Petrenko -> Goddard.

But now i'm annoyed, because i should have done Mitch Brown -> Riewoldt, now that M. Brown is out with a hamstring injury. Stupid Thursday trading....  :'(

Chief Runs With Beer

Don't panic - it's well publicised that Mitch Brown is part of the main West Coast landscape. He'll slot back into the squad when he is available.

StantonLEGEND

why would you do trades on thursday dude...

yogibbear

as i'm in WA, so i'm at work when lockout ends on fridays...