Rioli Vs Sylvia

[RichoMan94]

Who is the better player to put in the forward line??  ???

[MightyLions]

Sylvia for uniqueness! :)

[Titan Tim]

Rioli for SC, Sylvia for DT

[BratPack]

Rioli for SC, Sylvia for DT

+1

[Talisman]

Kinda surprised how popular Sylvia is. To me it's Rioli, hands down... But this is the joy of SuperCoach - everyone's got an opinion & who knows who'll end up being right!!! Gotta love it!

Now, where did I put that crystal ball...  ;) (if only!)

[sid3bysid3]

sylvia has had his chance - i think melbournes young guys are going to start to turn it on and steal some of his points.

dont think he uses the footy well enough to be a sc legend - but who woulda thought swanny would explode like he did.

here is to good guessing. im sticking with rioli though (playing a quarterback hodgesk role)

delicious

[Boomz]

Rioli.
Sylvia is a DT player... Think he may improve his average slightly but Rioli will be more consistent.

[meow meow]

Neither. Got too many with the bye in round 6 in the forward line as it is, so Cyril will be an upgrade target IF he is ripping it to shreds. He might be a dud at half back, who knows? I think Sylvia will pump his average up to near 100, if he can stay on the park. Goal kicking mids are what supercoach is all about. Swan/Ablett are perfect examples.

[Purple 77]

sylvia for me, he's over his injuries

[Fletch74]

sylvia for me, he's over his injuries

Rioli apparently blitzed yesterday against Richmond. He has a far higher ceiling than Sylvia. Therefore Rioli by a country mile!!

[H1bb3i2d]

He played the whole game in the middle, but even clarko said, when all their midfielders come back into the team Cyril will only'pinch hit' in the middle

[Alex7089]

Sylvia for uniqueness! :)

Neither of them are exactly unique :P
Rioli, has better disposal, will get more of it at half back and he can push forward and kick goals. Sylvia is DT through and through. He has never played 20 games in a season. Therefore he is an SC no go zone.