Rate Plz, Which one out of 3 Forward line and Rucks??

[Wookie]

Backline and Midfield i like but not sure about ruck and forwards, so which is the best out of these three???

B: B Goddard, C Cornes, J Drummond, N Malceski, J Smith, A Raines, S Hill
Emerg. L Greenwood, D O'Keefe

M: J Bartel, C Judd, S Burgoyne, S Tuck, Brad Ebert, D Rich
Emerg. J Ziebell, P Dangerfield

R1: D Hille, B Ottens
Emg: A Cordy, D Currie

F1: M Pavlich, L Franklin, J Brown, B Fevola, P Veszpremi, S Higgin, H Skipworth
Emg: H Ballantyne, T Walker

or

R2: D Cox, B Ottens

F2: M Pavlich, L Franklin, J Brown, J Riewoldt, P Veszpremi, S Higgin, H Skipworth

or

R3: B Ottens, T Simmonds

F3: M Pavlich, L Franklin, J Brown, M Richardson , P Veszpremi, S Higgin, H Skipworth

[SpeedMeades]

Ebert has OP, swap for Masten.

No.2 - simply because of Cox.

[Wookie]

ha, yeah i thought everyone would go with the cox view. what surgery is ebert having? i knew he had groin soreness but surgery??

[BU1101]

Good team! serious risk of injury or 0point players in your back line although it does look good now. JWS is still battling injury. Play a rookie forward to save 100-150 to and put hill on the bench as a security measure. And I agree Cox is a must.

[Wookie]

alright....... changed a bit, but haven't touched the backline, i think i will live or die by it.... but what about this??

D: B Goddard, C Cornes, J Drummond, N Malceski, J Smith, A Raines, S Hill
Emg. D O'Keefe, J Petrenko

M: J Bartel, C Judd, S Burgoyne, P Hasleby, Brad Ebert (maybe Masten), D Rich
Emg. J Zeibell, P Dangerfield

R: D Cox, D Petrie
Emg. D Currie, A Cordy

F: M Pavlich, L Franklin, J Brown, B Fevola, S Higgins, H Skipworth, N Krakouer
Emg. W Thompson, T Walker

Also i heard a rumour that Bartel and Harley word driving around the fringe in Adelaide, when Bartel saw a purse snatcher, hopped out of the car, chased him down and made a citizens arrest, bahaha, what a ledge.