goodwin vs franklin

[krajit06]

I dont know who to trade in for harvey goodwin or franklin :-\

[Watto]

Goodwin will be more reliable,
but Franklin will get some very big score + he's due for one soon


But probably Goodwin

[BlueBoy]

quite simply franklin has been double (sometimes triple) teamed.  He's also been roaming a lot. 

Franklin has suffered heaps from hawthorn's back 6 being missing for much of the start of the year.  He's still one or two more price drops away i think.  But carlton this week, might be the one.  I'd wait for franklin, then get him...hawthorn will be back.

Adelaide and Goodwin are a bit more risky.  I agree Franklin is highly inconsistant, but did you see what he could do last year?  I hate the guy, but he'll be in my team purely because he's dirt cheap for what he can do.

[ronl]

if I'm not mistaken Goodwin had a good start to the year last year then fell away second half of the season...think that may be a trend with him, be wary.

[Pravis]

I'd go Goodwin. Franklin is being steam rolled by too many defenders.