Have a crack at this please!

Colty · February 03, 2011, 02:59:09 PM

Goddard
Gibbs
Delidio
Broughton
Malceski
Otten
Heppel
Emerg - A Hooper, Toy Strauss

J Selwood
Pendlebury
Jack
Anthoney
Gaff
Mzungu
Emerg - Buckley, Jolly, Blease

Mumford
Tippett
Emerg - Charman, Bailey

Rioli
Riewaldt
Riewaldt
Higgins
Knights
okieefe
Petrie
Emerg - Matera, Krakour, Darling

I've tried to go with guys who are multi positioned. Subs are certainly subject to change after NAB Cup. Please have a dip at that, thank boys.

ando_10 · February 03, 2011, 04:53:39 PM

pretty well spread id probably put petrie in the ruck

i like ya side though mate a few uniques in the 9/10 for me :)

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,24800.0.html

j959 · February 03, 2011, 05:05:06 PM

Quote from: ando_10 on February 03, 2011, 04:53:39 PM
pretty well spread id probably put petrie in the ruck

Petrie in the ruck generally gives you money to spend elsewhere.

I'm a swans supporter but think Malsexi as your no5 could probably be mid-pricer/fallen premium - i just think you're selecting him as a premium unless you think he's going to up his avg to super-premium status.

Mummy had knee surgery didn't he?? just check his health status mate and have some back up alternates in case. Petrie over Tippett IMO.

which O'Keefe in your fwd-line??

Mantis · February 03, 2011, 05:12:45 PM

like some of your uniques, but one way to start your side is to pick in your own opinion the best player in that position then build around it, sandilands or at least someone close to him should be in your rucks. its really hard trying to upgrade ruckman, can tend to waste a few trades.

Defence - Goddard good
Mids - Selwood good
Rucks - insert premium here haha
Forwards - Riewoldt good

thats just my opinion mate, but some real good uniques and some good mid priced players in your side

Colty · February 04, 2011, 10:00:57 AM

Nice one, thanks alot boys.

The Malceski one is a funny one, i;ve read that he has smashed his PB's in all his time trials and is working very hard. I also noted that he may be spending more time in the midfield which to be honest was the clincher for me, I can certainly see the concern that he may not reach premium status, ill monitor his nab cup form and see what happens.
Maybe re rucks upgrade Mummy for Sandi and insert Petrie for Tippet? My aim with having the Petrie and Tippet in the same side was for Multi positional purposes. I do like Mummy and I think he might be able to get up to premium status but at the same time I dont want to be left behind if Sandi has another massive season.
The Okeefe in my forward line is Ryan from the Swans.

Great comments from you lads anyway. Post your sides here if you would like me to have a dip at them.

Cheers

Colty.

Mantis · February 04, 2011, 11:48:18 AM

Unique picks are needed though mate, so don't wanna fault the malceski and mumford pick too much, malceski may be one of those players you go with gut on and hope it pays off, haha you have a solid side and with 24 trades it wouldnt hurt you too much if malceski or mumford didn't come off.

Colty · February 04, 2011, 12:26:40 PM

Yeah thanks Mantis
I've fiddled with it a bit, and kept Mummy and Cheski, but traded Charman for J Tippett, K Tippett for Jolly, that way I can still use Petrie as a 3rd ruck though J Tippets multi position ability
So Mummy and Jolly with Petrie able to come in to cover?