Rate me my friends

Started by mattyondrums, February 02, 2011, 11:01:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mattyondrums

So how about rating my team thanks=D

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Malceski, Heppel, A.Otten, B.Jacobs, (Talia, Toy, Faulks)

Mids: Swan, Selwood, Judd, Goodes, D.Swallow, Gaf (Caddy, Atley, Wallis)

Rucks: Sandilands, Kreuzer (Z.Smith, Bailey)

Forwards: Harvey, Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Hurley, Knights, Prestia (Mzungu, Tapscott, Matera)

207k left over still so I've got a bit to play with.
Thoughts?

juzzyj

Forwards are very weak
not sure on Juddy or Goodes
Upgrade Eski to a delidio
Maybe Kreuzer is a slight risk also
and leave me right out of Hurley
Nice enough draft but i would be spending the cash on some upgrades

mattyondrums

Yeah I'm also not sure on Judd, he's never been a high dt scorer, will most likely change him for Bartel.

I've already got Deledio :P
I was happy with Goodes last year so I might keep him.
Kreuzer is a risk yes but I'm willing to take it a long with Hurley.

pardz

Upgrade harvey to chapman, get rid of kreuzer, upgrade hurley

70/100

McRooster

Backs - I like the unique pick of Malceski over the typical Broughton/Duffield. Esky played all 22 last year and has been dominating the 3km time trial pre season - he looks set to rip this season up.
Unfortunately Jacobs will have to come out as he has been struck down with Glandular fever and sent home to Victoria to recover. With so much spare cash you could roll the dice on the typical pick of Adcock instead ???
Mids - Excellent spread of talent, however your #2 mid Selwood will have to meet the pine in the Semi Final of rnd22 - is that where you want to have 450k sitting in a finals match, I think not.
Rucks - Kreuzer? Bravery or foolhardy? I'd err on the side of Petrie  ;)
Fwds - Triple H - Harvey, Higgins and Hurley, you should introduce another 2 H's and give them the old Heave Ho IMO. Begin with Goodes into your fwd line and replace him in your mids with Anthony. Add Franklin or Rioli and maybe Petterd.

Good team with scope for improvement - 70/100 is about right.