Defence!!

[cozza123]

what do you think the best defender is at the $345k mark??

[redfield]

You could look at McMahon, Shaw, Walker and Adcock I reckon.

[cozza123]

what about eric mackenzie?? the woed is he is set for a massive year!!

[Barlow 21]

McMahon, Shaw, Walker and Mackenzie are all poor options. Adcock and Otten are the only bargains from the $200k to $350k price-range.

[redfield]

McMahon, Shaw, Walker and Mackenzie are all poor options. Adcock and Otten are the only bargains from the $200k to $350k price-range.

Wouldn't really know about Mackenzie and I agree with you on Shaw and Walker but could you enlighten me as to why you feel that McMahon is a poor option. He was dropped for disciplinary reasons last year so he clearly wasn't in the right headspace. If he has gotten the message then I don't see why he couldn't return to his 90ppg average.

[JSelwood14]

Could Look at either of Otten, Hurley, or adcock.

[HillHero13]

i wouldn't get anyone around there.

get someone cheap and upgrade someone else, everyone around that price are either taggers, 2nd year players, or just useless players.

[sid3bysid3]

agree with hilly... lessons learnt in years gone past.

unless a player is reduced price due to injury, dont buy a 350-450k player.

they are at that price because that is the best they can score.

also, second year players are no good... steele sidebottom the exception they normally dont give you much value for money