first time.. so give me as much criticism as possible :)

[pyronerd]

a good looking unique team BS, i would personally trade daisy for sidebottom, and heath shaw a bit inconsistent for me, and no swan a big gamble 8.5/10 though, i do think its better then the first team

Daisy>Sidebottom, im not falling into this sidebottom hype thsi year.
Heath shaw true is inconsistent i personally wouldnt have in my team but hes not the worst.
Swan is no must, id pefer teams without him actually, as long as u have BGoddard ur fine

sidebottom = cheaper and will become premium this year IMO

[Knowall]

Increased his average pretty much 20pts to 84 in 2010.  For him to become a prem hell have to considerably increase that average again in his third year.  Two years in a row for a player so young seems unlikely for me

[BoredSaint]

im gonna keep shaw cause he's gonna be unique if everyone thinks like you pyro :P
and i like daisy over sidebottom as we dunno if sidebottom will improve much again this year.

[Luigi197]

updated team.. which one is better?

BoredSaint Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by BoredSaint. Salary cap left: $11,500.

Brendon Goddard, Graham Johncock, Corey Enright, Chris Newman, Heath Shaw, Dyson Heppell, Ben Jacobs
Sam Iles, Cameron Richardson, Josh Toy

Chris Judd, Brett Deledio, Matthew Pavlich, Liam Anthony, David Swallow, Andrew Gaff
Xavier Clarke, Sam Blease, Andrew Krakouer

Aaron Sandilands, Drew Petrie
Max Bailey, Zac Smith

Nick Riewoldt, Lance Franklin, Cyril Rioli, Dale Thomas, Colin Sylvia, Chris Knights, Dion Prestia
Jack Darling, Tendai Mzungu, Luke Tapscott

try fit in Deledio and/or Gibbs in the back and trade Johncock down to a cash cow
if above is done then deledio for Swan

[BoredSaint]

kinda need deledio as my CB to swap with goddard..

[Luigi197]

kinda need deledio as my CB to swap with goddard..

then how about just Newman to Gibbs if possible?
You've got Deledio so no need for Newman IMO i think

[MTTY]

. Great unique backline  ;), very different to some on here.

. Pretty unique mids that could pay off for you.

. Locked rucks, great choices.

. And great forwards dont have a problem with Waite but if he looks lik he cant control himself in nab then drop him.

overall 9/10 ;)

[BoredSaint]

kinda need deledio as my CB to swap with goddard..

then how about just Newman to Gibbs if possible?
You've got Deledio so no need for Newman IMO i think

would prefer to have newman over gibbs since he's more unique.. (BECAUSE ALL THE TEAMS ON HERE HAVE GIBBS >:()

[Luigi197]

kinda need deledio as my CB to swap with goddard..

then how about just Newman to Gibbs if possible?
You've got Deledio so no need for Newman IMO i think

would prefer to have newman over gibbs since he's more unique.. (BECAUSE ALL THE TEAMS ON HERE HAVE GIBBS >:()

i guess it dosent really matter if everyone has ppl... i can almost bet ya your team will change once SC opens... i sence suprise changes

[BoredSaint]

ahaha.. well i want a unique team which scores well.. so might stick with newman for now.. BUT you never know when SC starts :P